Over on Discarded Lies
, Hellenic hellkitten zorkmidden
posted a link to this surprising political cartoon from an Arab artist
. If you have trouble with the link to the image, it depicts a (brown) "Muslim Tsunami Victim" accepting an armful of cash and care packages from a (white) "Western Infidel," while meanwhile an "Arab Muslim," who's hefting a suitcase full of money, tosses a coin over his shoulder as he walks away
from the "Muslim Tsunami Victim."
What's surprising about the cartoon, of course, is that an Arab political voice gives some moral credit to the West and criticizes his own society -- it's uncommon enough to see one or the other, but to get both at the same time!
Anyway, there were different interpretations of the cartoon over on the Discarded Lies thread, which you can read for yourself. But I wanted to re-post my own observation about the cartoon, as I think there's a lesson from the Judeo-Christian tradition that we should be quietly soft-selling, in Arabic and other languages of the Islamic world. Islam's apologists like to point out that Muslims revere Isa al-Masih, "Jesus the Messiah," as one of their prophets, yet the Gospels -- along with the rest of the Bible -- are taboo to Muslims, so they seldom get a chance to find out what JC had to say. (If you're a new reader, I should disclose that I'm not a Christian and do not regard Jesus as divine or infallible -- so when I recommend his wisdom to Muslims, I do so in the same spirit that I might urge them to reflect on a particular quotation from Socrates, or Jefferson, or Twain.)
Anyhew, going back to the cartoon:
I wonder if the cartoonist is familiar with Jesus' story of the Good Samaritan -- if not, then he has independently come to the same insight expressed by that parable. A lot of people who know the phrase "Good Samaritan" miss an important point: namely, that to Jews of Jesus' time, Samaritans were (take your pick) "niggers," "untouchables," "kaffir," "heathens," etc.
posted by Throbert |
2/02/2005 11:15:00 PM |
In the story, after the upright Jewish citizen is attacked by bandits and left to die of his wounds, several pillars of Jewish society notice his plight, but decline to help. In the end, it is the [ptui!] Samaritan who helps the Jew, dresses his wounds, takes him to an inn, and leaves money to cover the man's room and board while he recuperates. "Who was truly a good neighbor to the man?" asked Jesus. Answer: The "nigger/kufr/untouchable."
I'm fairly sure I read somewhere that the basic model of the Good Samaritan story predates Jesus in the rabbinical tradition by a few hundred years, at least -- thus, this meme is shared by Jews and Christians. To all appearences, its lesson is totally alien to the Arab Muslim mindset.
01 February 2005
Gay movies I like
Re-posted from the comments section of GayPatriot:
I generally shy away from movies that are aimed "at us," as they tend to make me feel like I'm at a mandatory-attendance pep rally in high school. Hooray! It's good to be gay because gay men are stylish and witty and fashionable!
My feeling is: No, it's good to be gay because men are sexy and lovable, and dicks are delicious. All that stuff about creativity and wit and fashion sense is secondary, and often untrue -- or at least, not true of gay men any more than straight men. A lot of gay men are NOT very witty or creative or well-read or good with colors, but often they have other great qualities, and it irks me no end when "gay positive" movies aspire to nothing more stroking the vanity of a narrow urban subset of gays.
Okay, with that rant out of the way, some gay-themed movies that I like:
Yossi & Jagger, about the love affair between a young Israeli soldier and his slightly older sergeant, is incredibly powerful. If the ending doesn't make straight conservatives understand what a dehumanizing obscenity the closet is, I don't know what can. Plus, you've got gay guys as soldiers. And those hot Jewish men made my shaygetz sausage sizzle!
Bedrooms and Hallways is a fun British dramedy about a frumpy gay man who goes to this New Age men's encounter group, where he develops a crush on a hunky butch straight guy, who turns out to be not completely straight. Will gay man make a match with hunky butch bi guy, or will hunky butch bi guy find another hunky butch bi guy and fly off into the sunset? (Hint: Who were the most contented and happy homos by the end of Boys in the Band? Hank and Larry, the butch couple.)
No one has mentioned Urbania, which has the love between two gay men at its center, though I can't say much more without spoiling it.
Personally, I would be thrilled to see Hollywood do the Gilgamesh epic, which presents a male/male couple who are brawny warriors and tender lovers. But I'm not holding my breath.
Finally, I have to mention that I found Heavenly Creatures to be an incredibly affecting portrayal of adolescent same-sex love, despite the fact that the lovers turn out to be murderers. I want a ♪♫♭ Donkey Serenade ♪♫♭ montage in my next relationship, dammit!
posted by Throbert |
2/01/2005 02:09:00 AM |